Skip to content
AlphaHeadline delivers the latest breaking news, technology…

The Educational Messaging Spotlighted by an Oscar-Winning Film – But Does It Effective?

After her seven-year-old daughter was told to recite a poem celebrating Russia's "powerful army" for a class activity, one parent from Moscow believed it was over the top.

She has faced difficulties to protect her child from a growing number of so-called "patriotic" activities in the education system.

This escalation of military propaganda directed toward the country's students has been vividly brought to life for a international audience in an Oscar-winning documentary.

The film, created by a former teacher and videographer from a provincial town in the Ural mountains, documents how educational activities were progressively integrated with state narratives following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

What worries the mother deeply is that her daughter actually enjoys participating in the government-sponsored initiative.

"She likes her teacher, she gets along with her classmates – she enjoys being a part of it," she says.

She fears that openly objecting to school activities could socially isolate her daughter. Once, when she kept her child home to skip a flag-raising ceremony, her daughter was disappointed. "My concern is her to think like she doesn't belong," she adds.

The Film's Insights

The documentary shows how the filmmaker was reluctantly drawn into the state propaganda apparatus.

New rituals and compulsory lessons were introduced, aimed at teaching the official perspective on history and current events.

Educational materials were revised to incorporate the ongoing conflict, referred to as a "special operation."

These diktats have continued. Recently, the education ministry announced plans for a official list of play materials for preschools to promote "patriotism."

The intended messages are clear: the military campaign is defensive, and loyalty requires unquestionable support. At home, however, some families hear contrasting views.

Children's Perspectives

One young boy, Maksim, enthusiastically lists what he has learnt in his "patriotic education" lessons: subjects ranging from arts and culture to friendship and even robots and tanks.

"We were taught this is how to prepare for war," he says.

His mother, who opposes the war, avoids publicly discussing her views in front of him, concerned he might share it in public.

"A vocal anti-war position might attract unnecessary attention," the mother says.

Expert Insight

Navigating the gap between school messages and family beliefs is difficult, says a psychotherapist.

"A child has to live in the school setting – going to school, being part of the group," the expert notes. "However, this isn't parents should align with the propaganda. But there is no need in adopting a political stance in front of your child."

She suggests parents emphasize universal values like the importance of human life and peaceful conflict resolution – rather than openly challenging the school narratives.

Research indicate younger children are particularly susceptible to messages from teachers and leaders. "If you tell a small child that war is good, they will accept it," the psychotherapist adds.

"If parents consistently disagree with state messaging, family influence usually wins out in the long run," states a researcher in social psychology.

However, when the state controls most sources of information and different viewpoints are scarce, the long-term effect is less predictable. This describes the current Russian context.

Research into past indoctrination have found that school-based messaging can have enduring effects, especially when supported by the broader social environment.

Uneven Application

The application of government guidelines differs significantly across schools.

Certain schools follow them zealously, while others soften or quietly resist the requirements. Educators may modify, minimize, or avoid the prescribed content.

In footage from the documentary, children are shown given Russian flags during a school assembly to watch a announcement about a state-run children's movement.

In a separate lesson, a class is warned that the "enemy" will try to influence from within their communities.

Student Apathy

The patriotic lessons, known as "Conversations about Important Things," are often met with indifference by older students.

One 14-year-old from St Petersburg, Maia, complains they are "tedious."

"Hardly anyone engages in the discussion. We just are present and pretend to listen, then go," she describes.

"Compelling citizens to engage in public displays of patriotism is a way of demonstrating them of the regime's overwhelming power," notes a academic expert in Russian studies. This feeling is reinforced by state-run media and orchestrated public discourse, the professor states.

In a move to leverage this "environment," authorities simplified the process for graduates to join the military in 2023, at times offering financial incentives as motivation.

The teenager, who holds her parents' opposing view of the war, does not discuss at school and is unsure what her classmates truly think.

"At first I was worried that I would clash with those who support the war," she recalls. "But nowadays, people behaves so neutrally that the atmosphere seems normal."

About the author

Benjamin Palmer

Award-winning journalist with over 15 years of experience covering technology and global affairs, passionate about uncovering stories that matter.

AlphaHeadline

Type to search articles.